Early in my career I stood up at a town hall with my whole speech written out in front of me, like the good girl I was at the time, and my hands shook so hard that the paper shook with them. I could see it happening.
Afterwards a mentor of mine sat me down and explained that nobody out there had seen a thing. I was too far away, and the only human in the room watching that paper was me. I've repeated his words to every woman I've coached on speaking since.
That's mentoring doing precisely what mentoring is for. What it didn't do was get me a bigger job.
Across more than 35 years inside one organisation I've had mentors, sponsors and coaches, and they are three genuinely different things. A career mentor gets most of the attention in conversations about women's careers, and sponsorship and coaching are what actually moved mine.
In this post, we'll explore
- What a career mentor, a sponsor and a coach each actually do
- Whose reputation is sitting on the line in each one
- How you get hold of each, and what it asks of you
- Which one to reach for with six weeks of the year left
Difference one: what each one actually does
A career mentor has been somewhere near where you're headed and tells you what they saw, handing over perspective, pattern recognition and the occasional shortcut. That shaky paper conversation is the whole job in one moment.
A sponsor does something else entirely, talking about your skills when you aren't in the room and putting your name forward.
A coach hands you no answers at all, and asks the question that makes your own blind spot impossible to keep ignoring.
I got one of those at my own kitchen table. I'd been circling a face-to-face training program for a year and the content and the money were both fine... it was the leaving my house to learn with other humans part. When I said so, Scotty put his coach hat on and told me that resisting it was the exact reason to do it. I enrolled that night.
Difference two: whose judgement is on the line
This is the difference nobody explains, and it's the one that matters most. When a mentor gives you advice, nothing of theirs is at stake, so you can ignore every word and they've lost nothing. A sponsor is wagering their own credibility on you, saying in front of people whose opinion of them counts that you're worth backing.
Here's what that looks like. I was in the back of a taxi in Hong Kong, rain hammering down outside, when my phone started going mad with congratulations and not one person saying what for. Then a video arrived from my team at a gala in Sydney, and there was my name being read out as the national award winner for achievement in operations, technology or customer support.
I sat there stunned, because I haven't worked in operations for years and I have never once worked in technology. Somebody had written the case for me and put their own name against it, and there was nothing I could have done about it from the back of a taxi. Which is rather the point.
Difference three: how you get one, and what it asks of you
Mentors you can ask for outright, and one of mine arrived as a gift: when I finally asked my boss for a four day week he said yes on the spot, then offered to find me a mentor to help me run a big job on a reduced week. (I'd already told my husband, my best friend and my coach that the answer would be no. I probably told the cat.)
A coach you choose and invest in, and the asking is the easy part, because being coached is humbling and it's regularly realising you don't have the answers.
Sponsors can't be requested, so what you can do is make yourself sponsorable, and that's a short list. Know who already speaks well of you. Keep them informed about what you want next. Talk about outcomes and why they mattered, rather than everything you got through this week. Because humans are shocking mind readers, and nobody is going to narrate your contribution on your behalf.
Difference four: when each one moves something
Reach for a mentor when you're facing something they've already survived, and reach for a coach when you keep arriving at the same spot and can't see why. Sponsorship moves the big things, every time, which is why I bang on about keeping your people informed.
All three ask the same thing of you first, though. You have to know what you want next, because a mentor can't aim at it and a sponsor certainly can't argue for it while it's vague.
Complete Career Clarity
Want to know what you're asking for before the year ends?
My 60 minute recorded working session to work out what you actually want next, with the exercises, the companion workbook and the Career Certainty Reset. $27 AUD, instant access, and a 7-day satisfaction guarantee.
Yes! I'm ready to get clear on what I want nextFinal thoughts: which one is right for you?
Smart women don't work it all out on their own. They invest in the right support, and it isn't a luxury.
So if there's a hurdle in front of you, find the mentor who has cleared it. If you keep landing in the same place, a coach is your answer. Either way, spend the next six weeks telling the humans who speak for you what you're after next year, because the conversations that shape it are happening right now.
Six weeks is plenty for one honest conversation.
So tell me, who speaks for you when you're not in the room, and do they know what you want next? I'd love for you to share with all of us in the comments below.
See you in the next one. But until then, stay fabulous xx